A Judge Says the DOJ’s Noncitizen List Isn’t Credible. Six Days Out, the Same Playbook Is Running in Washington and Alaska.
Judge David Carter refused to sideline 20,000 California mail ballots. The Justice Department is appealing, and it has already aimed the same tactics at two more states.
By Mike Dean,
By Daily Rumble | October 29, 2026
A federal judge on Wednesday refused the Justice Department’s demand that California set aside mail ballots from roughly 20,000 people the government says are not citizens. In a 26-page decision, U.S. District Judge David Carter called the government’s method for building its list “vague” and wrote that he “cannot conclude that plaintiffs’ process is credible,” CBS News reported. “Never before in American history has the federal government, on the eve of an election, sought to coerce a state and local government to abandon their own Constitutional elections procedures and bend to the will of the Executive Branch,” Carter wrote. The department is taking it to the Ninth Circuit. Two days before the ruling, its prosecutors in Seattle had already handed Washington state a new list of 405 names and the same 48-hour ultimatum.

Huge Announcement Just Dropped at DRN
Step back and look at the calendar. On Oct. 15 the department sued California. On Oct. 22 it sued Alaska to block certification of a Senate race that has not happened yet. On Oct. 26 it sent Washington its letter. On Oct. 28 a judge said the method behind all of it does not hold up. Election Day is Tuesday, Nov. 3, and every one of these deadlines runs straight into it.
So here is the question the week forces. If a federal judge cannot find the government’s list credible, why is the department exporting the same approach to more states with six days left, and what is it building toward once the counting starts?
What the judge found when he looked at the list
The California case collapsed on its own data. Los Angeles County told the court that only just over 7,000 of the 20,000 records had county addresses, according to CBS News. In a sample of 200, more than half matched registrations that were canceled or inactive, so no ballot had even been mailed. Of the sampled voters who listed a birthplace, just over 38 percent said they were born in the United States. A U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services official, Nicolas Bartell, countered that the agency’s records showed none of the 200 were U.S.-born. In the same declaration he acknowledged roughly 189 records on the list “with minor data discrepancies.”
Carter also looked east. In Nevada, he wrote, the Department of Homeland Security “initially identified up to 15,903 registered voters as noncitizens.” After manual review the number fell to 185, and “Nevada officials later confirmed that all 185 individuals were citizens,” NBC News reported from the ruling.
“Individuals who have met the requirements of California’s voter registration laws must not be deprived of a core right merely because of unfounded allegations stemming from a procedure rife with uncertainty and errors,” Carter wrote.
Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, answered with urgency. “Every day, more ballots are processed by election officials. This ongoing emergency disenfranchises American citizens through dilution,” he said. The appeals court had already weighed that word. On Monday a Ninth Circuit panel dismissed the department’s earlier bid 2 to 1, and Judge Mark Bennett wrote for the majority that the “claimed emergency” was at least partly “a self-constructed one,” per NBC News.
The remedy the department already has
Carter kept pointing prosecutors at the tool they already hold. “The remedy as a good prosecutor is to make sure these people are prosecuted,” he told the government’s lawyers at Tuesday’s hearing, according to CBS News. Returned ballot envelopes carry identifying information, he noted, so anyone who voted illegally can be charged after the election. NBC News reported that he cited the department’s own announcement of “28 indictments” in California and told the lawyers, “Go out and indict.”
Twenty-eight. Against a list of 20,000. The department chose to ask a court to hold ballots before the count instead of charging people after it, and a judge appointed by Bill Clinton had to remind it which of those two things the law actually gives a prosecutor.
Washington got the same treatment anyway. Neil Floyd, the acting U.S. attorney in Seattle, and Pete Serrano, the top federal prosecutor in eastern Washington, told Secretary of State Steve Hobbs on Monday that 405 registered voters were noncitizens who had cast more than 1,500 ballots. “This is only the tip of the iceberg,” Floyd said. The list came from DHS. The secretary of state’s office found a record for one person who last voted in 1994. So far, CBS News reported, the department has only sent a letter and has not filed a lawsuit, while warning it would seek “emergency relief.”
Hobbs told OPB there have been 15 instances of noncitizens voting in Washington from 1982 to 2025. “We saw what happened in California and don’t want Washingtonians to be harassed,” he said in a statement.
What’s actually happening beneath the surface
Alaska shows where this goes. The department’s suit there, filed Oct. 22, asks a court to bar certification of the Senate result under two conditions: Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan does not win, and he would have won if every vote for a second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., had gone to him under ranked-choice counting. President Trump said he directed the suit, ABC News reported, and called the other Sullivan “the fake.” The filing, signed by Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, says “it is vital that Defendants not certify any election result that may be impacted by voter confusion.”
Alaska’s Supreme Court ruled in June that both men belong on the ballot, Al Jazeera reported, and the ballot lists the senator as the registered Republican incumbent. Derek Muller, an election law professor at Notre Dame, called the legal theory “so absurdly thin” that there was “essentially no likelihood of success.” Attorney General Todd Blanche said the department would only act in a “doomsday scenario.” The campaign of Mary Peltola, the Democrat who led the August primary with 49.5 percent to Sullivan’s 41.4, called the suit “a despicable political threat to overturn an election.”
Put the pieces side by side. Reuters documented more than 100 subpoenas across at least 13 states demanding records on tens of thousands of voters, according to Al Jazeera, which reported that legal experts say those records could be used to contest close results. The department has sued 30 states and the District of Columbia for complete voter rolls, and federal judges have tossed 27 of those suits, CBS News reported. A government whistleblower warned in a court filing, per Al Jazeera, that “the current process is knowingly sweeping known US citizens in as potentially ‘unlawful voters.’”
None of this needs to win in court to work. A list that cannot survive review can still be read aloud at a press conference. A certification fight in Alaska can still be on file the morning after a close count.
What to watch
Watch the Ninth Circuit first, and how fast it moves with ballots still being processed. Watch Washington, where prosecutors say DHS will send a second list “imminently” and where a lawsuit is the next step they have threatened. And watch whether any of the 405 people Floyd named are ever charged with a crime, because that is the test Carter set.
If the government had proof that thousands of noncitizens were voting, it would not need a 48-hour deadline. It would need a grand jury, and it already has those. What it is asking states to do instead is hold lawful votes in limbo on the strength of lists that keep shrinking every time someone checks them. Remember that when the same names come up again after Tuesday.
🗞️ Daily Rumble is powered by Quwwaa — independent news without the establishment filter. Read more and download the app at quwwaa.com.
We’re not funded by a network, a party, or anyone with an agenda to protect. We’re funded by people like you — people who’d rather support media that tells the truth than scroll past it. For $5 a month, you’re not just reading Daily Rumble — you’re making sure it keeps existing, keeps growing, and keeps showing up for the stories the big outlets won’t touch. Subscribe today, and become part of the reason independent journalism survives.
Sources:
CBS News — Judge rejects Trump administration’s push to force California to set aside thousands of mail ballots — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/judge-rejects-trump-california-mail-ballots/
NBC News — Judge declines to block California from counting alleged noncitizen voters’ ballots in DOJ lawsuit — https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/judge-rules-california-ballots-alleged-non-citizen-voters-trump-doj-rcna606100
Al Jazeera — Judge rejects Trump effort to block California ‘noncitizen’ ballots — https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/10/29/judge-rejects-trump-effort-to-block-california-noncitizen-ballots
CBS News — Justice Department asks Washington state to set aside ballots from 400 alleged noncitizens — https://www.cbsnews.com/news/justice-department-washington-ballots-400-alleged-noncitizens/
OPB — Federal attorneys allege hundreds of non-citizens are voting in Washington elections — https://www.opb.org/article/2026/10/26/federal-attorneys-allege-hundreds-of-non-citizens-are-voting-in-washington-elections/
ABC News — Trump told DOJ to sue to block Alaska Senate results if Republican narrowly loses — https://abcnews.com/US/doj-preemptively-sues-block-alaska-senate-results-republican/story?id=137512876

